Skip to content

2012-2013 Tahoe Lawsuit against Guatemalan Government

In June 2012, Minera San Rafael, S.A., a wholly-owned subsidiary of Tahoe Resources Inc., commenced a lawsuit in the Constitutional Court of Guatemala alleging that “community protests had ‘impeded its work,’ including the construction of an electrical transmission line through a road allowance in the neighbouring municipality of Mataquescuintla. The lawsuit named the President of the Republic of Guatemala, Ministry of the Interior, Ministry of National Defence, Director of the National Police, Commissioner of the National Police in the Department of Jalapa, and the Commissioner of National Police in the Department of Santa Rosa. It accused them of failing in their duties to protect the mine” (JCAP, 2017). The Court dismissed the lawsuit in February 2013, finding that that government had acted within its legal capacities, having provided security and strategic contingency plans to ensure order and security within the region.

Type of Action / Tipo de Acción:
Constitutional Proceedings
Legal Description / Descripción Legal:
Corte de Constitucionalidad [Constitutional Court], 26 February 2013, Expediente 2728-2012
Extractive Project / Proyecto extractivo:
Region / Región:
Central America
Country / País:
Guatemala
Natural Resource / Recurso natural:
Gold, Lead, Silver, Zinc
Jurisdiction / Jurisdicción:
Guatemalan System
Category of Key Actors in Legal Action / Categoría de actores claves en la Acción Legal:
Company(ies), Politicians and/or Political Parties, State Institutions
Key Legal Actors Involved / Actores jurídicos clave involucrados:
Commissioner of National Police in the Department of Santa Rosa, Director of the National Police, Commissioner of the National Police in Department of Jalapa, Minera San Rafael, S.A., Ministry of National Defence, Ministry of the Interior, Republic of Guatemala, Tahoe Resources Inc.
Year Action Started / Año de inicio:
2012
References / Referencias:

Corte de Constitucionalidad [Constitutional Court], 26 February 2013, Expediente 2728-2012, online: http://138.94.255.164/Sentencias/821984.2728-2012.pdf, accessed 8 December 2020

Justice and Corporate Accountability Project (JCAP), “Request to Investigate Tahoe Resources for Failure to Disclose Material Information”, filed with British Columbia Securities Commission, dated 8 May 2017, online: https://miningwatch.ca/sites/default/files/final_bcsc_disclosure_complaint_re_tahoe_-_may_15_2017.pdf, accessed on 8 December 2020